News

Raiders: Why Kirk Cousins Must Start Over Fernando Mendoza

By
Published: Apr 3, 2026
fernando mendoza or kirk cousins heres who should start week 1 for raiders.jpg - Image Credit: Social Media/Agency

LAS VEGAS — The Las Vegas Raiders just pulled off the ultimate NFL offseason double-dip. They own the #1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft and just secured four-time Pro Bowler Kirk Cousins on a guaranteed $20 million deal. The desert is already buzzing with one question: Who takes the first snap against the world in September? While the hype for Indiana’s Heisman winner Fernando Mendoza is deafening, the smart money says the rookie needs to grab a clipboard and watch the master at work.

The Veteran Buffer

Mendoza is a certified stud. You don’t rack up 3,535 passing yards and an FBS-high 41 touchdowns while leading Indiana to a 16-0 national title without being a freak of nature. He is the future. But the NFL is a different beast entirely. It’s a league that eats young quarterbacks alive when they aren’t protected. By signing Cousins, the Raiders bought Mendoza the most valuable thing in sports: time. Cousins has seen every blitz, every coverage disguise, and every exotic look the league can throw at a passer. Mendoza can soak up that knowledge without the crushing pressure of a Week 1 start.

Think back to the 2025 season. We saw too many high-profile rookies forced onto the field before they could even find the cafeteria. They took hits. They threw picks. Their confidence cracked. The Raiders shouldn’t risk their “expensive sports car” in a Week 1 hailstorm. Let the 37-year-old veteran take the early-season lumps while the rookie adjusts to the pro game’s blistering speed.

“In a perfect world, he’s watching a mature adult go and run an offense and run the team. You’d rather him learn before he gets in the game.”
— Klint Kubiak, Raiders Head Coach

Kirk Cousins Still Has the Goods

Don’t mistake Cousins for a glorified coach in shoulder pads. Even at 37, he remains one of the most accurate pocket passers in the business. He isn’t here to just collect a check; he’s here to win. Last year, finishing his stint in Atlanta, he threw for 1,721 yards and 10 touchdowns in his final eight games alone. He knows Kubiak’s system from their Minnesota days. He will get the ball to playmakers on time. He keeps the offense out of third-and-long nightmares. If the Raiders start 4-2 under Cousins, Mendoza learns in a winning environment. If things go south, the rookie becomes the mid-season spark rather than a desperation heave.

Playoff Implications / What’s Next

The Raiders finished 3-14 last year, a record that secured them the right to draft Mendoza. However, the roster isn’t as barren as that record suggests. With a solid offensive line and a defense that kept games close, a steady hand at quarterback could easily double that win total. The AFC West is a meat grinder. Facing Mahomes and Herbert twice a year requires a level of mental processing that a rookie simply hasn’t developed yet. Starting Cousins isn’t a slight against Mendoza; it’s a strategic play to ensure the Raiders are relevant in December. Expect Mendoza to be the official pick on April 23 in Pittsburgh, but expect Captain Kirk to lead the huddle when the lights go up in September.

Follow NHANFL For Exclusive Updates

Tara McCarthy

Tara McCarthy is a Senior NFL Writer at nhanfl.com based in Chicago, IL. With a B.A. in Journalism and over 7 years of sports writing experience, she covers breaking NFL news, game analysis, and fantasy football insights. An expert in NFC team dynamics, Tara is dedicated to delivering accurate, timely reporting to football fans worldwide.

Email: tara@nhanfl.com
https://x.com/taranhanfl

Google Preferences →