PITTSBURGH — Omar Khan didn’t just rebuild the Steelers’ offensive line; he poured premium concrete into the foundation. But as the dust settles on the 2025 season, that foundation has a crack.
The Steelers protected 42-year-old quarterback Aaron Rodgers well enough to get him 17 starts in an 18-game grinder. But now, with a new coaching regime reportedly ushering in the Mike McCarthy era, Khan faces a decision that could define the franchise’s trajectory: What to do with Broderick Jones?
The Jones Dilemma: Potential vs. Production
Broderick Jones was supposed to be the anchor. Khan traded up to No. 14 in 2023 to get him. Yet, as the Steelers head into the 2026 offseason, Jones represents the biggest question mark on the roster.
Before a neck injury ended his season in late November, Jones was a liability. The numbers are ugly: six sacks allowed and 23 pressures in just 11 games. He was, statistically, the team’s worst lineman.
Now, Khan has until May 1 to decide on Jones’ fifth-year option for 2027. It’s a massive financial commitment for a player recovering from a neck injury the same type of injury that just forced former Steelers safety Ryan Watts into early retirement.
The Undrafted Savior?
While Jones struggled, an unlikely hero emerged. Dylan Cook, a 28-year-old former quarterback turned lineman, stepped in at left tackle and looked like he belonged. In four starts, Cook allowed just one sack. His footwork was crisp. His confidence was palpable.
Cook isn’t just a stopgap anymore; he’s a legitimate option. With only one year left on his deal, he complicates Khan’s math. Do you pay the pedigree (Jones) or the production (Cook)?
“We need that nasty. We need to be the guys finishing blocks when the whistle blows. It’s not just about keeping [Rodgers] clean; it’s about moving people against their will.”
— Steelers Offensive Source on the unit’s mentality for 2026
The Core Remains Strong
Despite the tackle controversy, the interior looks set for the next decade. Zach Frazier has developed into one of the league’s premier centers, allowing a single sack in 2025. Mason McCormick, the fourth-round gem from South Dakota State, has solidified the guard spot next to him.
The wild card is veteran Isaac Seumalo. At 32, he’s the elder statesman, but injuries cost him seven games over two years. Khan might look to get younger and cheaper—by turning to Spencer Anderson or dipping back into the draft.
Playoff Implications / What’s Next
The Steelers finished 26th in rushing yards per game last season. That won’t fly in the AFC North. Whether Rodgers returns for one last dance or the team pivots to a younger signal-caller, the mandate is clear: dominate the trenches.
Expect Khan to be active in the draft again. Names like Olaivavega Ioane (Penn State) and Francis Mauigoa (Miami) are already circling the radar. Khan built this line to dominate. Now, he has to make the tough cuts to ensure it actually does.
