DETROIT — The writing isn’t just on the wall; it’s in the box score. After a 2025 season where Jahmyr Gibbs exploded for 1,223 rushing yards and a definitive lead role, the “one-two punch” in Detroit has become a solo act. David Montgomery, once the engine of this offense, finished the year with a career-low 716 yards and just eight touchdowns.
The most damning stat? In his final eight games, Montgomery cracked eight rush attempts just one time. Now, General Manager Brad Holmes is signaling that the veteran back’s time in Honolulu Blue might be over before his age-29 season even begins.
The Gibbs Takeover is Complete
The changing of the guard didn’t happen gradually; it happened violently. While Montgomery battled through the grind, Gibbs turned into the superstar Detroit envisioned when they drafted him 12th overall. Gibbs didn’t just outpace Montgomery; he nearly doubled his production in key stretches.
Montgomery’s 158 carries in 2025 represent a steep drop-off, but the efficiency metrics are where the concern really lies. He struggled to create yards after contact at his usual rate, and without the volume to wear defenses down, his “bruiser” style lost its bite. For fantasy managers and Lions fans alike, the reality is stark: unless Gibbs goes down, Montgomery is now a touchdown-dependent flier with a capped ceiling.
Brad Holmes didn’t hide behind “coach speak” when asked about Montgomery’s future earlier this month. His comments suggest the front office is actively exploring trade partners to clear cap space and roster spots.
“Those are conversations that we’re going to have to have because I’ve got a lot of respect for that player. He deserves to be in a situation where his skill set can be utilized. And so yeah, would love it for it to be here, but if it can’t be here, then you would have to just see what you can work out the best for him.”
— Brad Holmes, Lions General Manager
The Business Decision
Here is the cold financial reality: Montgomery signed a two-year, $18.25 million extension back in October 2024 that ties him to Detroit through 2027. However, the structure allows Detroit to get out. A trade post-June 1 would save the Lions roughly $6 million against the cap.
With Gibbs due for a massive payday soon and the Lions needing cash to address other holes, paying a backup running back nearly $10 million a year is a luxury they can no longer afford. Expect Detroit to shop Montgomery to RB-needy teams like the Cowboys, Chargers, or potentially a reunion with an NFC North rival, although that remains unlikely.
What’s Next?
If Montgomery stays, he enters 2026 as an expensive insurance policy. If he goes, he likely lands in a committee elsewhere, but his days as a 250-touch workhorse are likely in the rearview mirror. For Detroit, the focus is clear: ride the hot hand of Jahmyr Gibbs and find a cheaper, younger option to spell him.
